Home » Food Sauce » 11 Of The Best Jack In The Box Sauces To Enhance Your Order!

11 Of The Best Jack In The Box Sauces To Enhance Your Order!

Maria Foster
Last Updated on
by Maria Foster

Jack In the Box is one of the most interesting fast food places in the country. The business started off as the perfect place to get a comical and unique dining experience that the whole family can enjoy.

However, since then it has successfully evolved into one of the most iconic burger joints in the U.S.

11 Of The Best Jack In The Box Sauces To Enhance Your Order!

If you are looking for somewhere fun to enjoy a casual meal with your loved ones, you can’t go wrong with Jack In The Box.

With that being said, there are some choices to make in the restaurant that are harder than others.

One of the most difficult choices to make at Jack In The Box is what sauce you should have with your food. In this guide, we will look at some of the best sauces available at Jack In The Box.

How Many Sauces Does Jack In The Box Offer?

Before we dive into the best sauces that you can get at Jack In The Box, you might be interested in finding out just how many sauces are on offer at the fast food establishment.

On the Jack In The Box menu, there are an amazing 27 sauces on offer. We told you choosing one would be a difficult decision.

Thankfully, while 27 is a very generous range of sauces, not all of them have made it onto our list of the best sauces from Jack In The Box.

We have brought together all of the best sauces from the chain that instantly elevate your meal and work with almost anything you can order from the menu.

1. Creamy Sriracha Sauce

Creamy Sriracha is one of the best sauces that you can get anywhere. It is the perfect combination of heat and cooling.

This may sound like the two cancel each other out. However, they actually create a sauce that allows you to add a kick to your food without it being overpowering.

The initial wave of heat that you get from creamy sriracha sauce works perfectly to enhance the texture and flavor of your meat. A wave of cooling creaminess quickly cools the heat before it overpowers the food.

This sauce is most commonly used on the chicken options that Jack In The Box serves. With that being said, there is no reason why it wouldn’t work just as well with a hamburger.

This is also a great sauce for dipping fries into to give them a burst of flavor and spice that really brings them to life.

2. Barbecue Sauce

Barbecue is a classic sauce that you can get in almost any fast food establishment. However, Jack In The Box seems to do Barbecue sauce exceptionally well. The barbecue sauce you get here has the perfect balance of tangy, sweet, and sticky.

One of the things that make barbecue sauce so popular is the fact that it truly goes with everything. You can put this sauce on your chicken burgers, and hamburgers, and dip your sides in it.

With that being said, most people seem to pair this sauce with hamburgers rather than chicken meals.

Something that seems to be a bit of a trend with barbecue sauce at Jack In The Box restaurants is dipping your fries in the barbecue sauce and putting them inside a burger that is already covered in the same sauce.

If you are unsure of what sauce you should get at Jack In The Box, barbecue sauce is always a strong choice.

3. Garlic Herb Butter

This is a sauce that is commonly used in the sandwiches that are sold at Jack In The Box restaurants.

The fresh garlic and herbs that are used in the butter provide a wonderfully strong flavor that works really well with chicken options.

The garlic herb butter sauce works really well as a dressing for your chicken salad as well as a sauce to drizzle over your chicken sandwiches.

It even works as a dip for your sides because the combination of garlic and herb seems to work with almost anything.

One of the best things about the garlic and herb sauce at Jack In The Box is the fact that the flavor lingers on your tongue for a while.

If you really like the flavor of the sauce this can be a huge benefit. However, it can also be a good idea to bring some breath mints with you if not.

To make this sauce even better, pairing it with a spicy order really brings out the flavor and cooling effects of the butter.

Despite the fact that the butter cools the spicy food down, it doesn’t take away from the amazing flavors and aromas of the food.

4. Sweet And Sour Sauce

Another classic fast food sauce is sweet and sour. Again, Jack In The Box seems to have nailed the recipe for their sauce. This sweet and sour sauce is the perfect mix of fruity and tangy.

Jack In The Box has taken their sweet and sour sauce to the next level by adding chunks of pineapple.

This helps to add an extra crunch to the sauce and makes it a taste sensation when paired with almost anything on the menu.

With that being said, the ultimate combination is the sweet and sour sauce with chicken sandwiches or salads.

This works so well because the flavor of the sauce seems to soak into the chicken and works really well with the texture of the meat.

5. Frank’s Red Hot Buffalo Sauce

If you are a fan of hot sauce, chances are that you enjoy a bit of Frank’s Red Hot Buffalo sauce from time to time.

Thankfully, this amazing hot sauce is available at Jack In The Box. This sauce provides the perfect kick of heat to anything you order from the Jack In The Box menu.

This sauce is labeled as a dipping sauce, however, there is no reason why you can’t put it in your burger, sandwich, or all over your sides or salad.

For anyone that enjoys having a spicy kick to their food, this is the only sauce you need from the 27 available at Jack In The Box.

This is a sauce that also pairs well with the garlic herb butter sauce if you want to layer your sauces and create a taste sensation with every bite of your meal.

6. Buttermilk House Dipping Sauce

If you are a frequent visitor to fast food restaurants, you will be well aware that house sauces can be a little bit hit-and-miss. They are either super flavorful or feel like a watered-down version of a much better sauce.

Thankfully, Jack In The Box seems to have got the formula right for their buttermilk house dipping sauce. This sauce is surprisingly similar to ranch dressing so it is perfect for anyone who loves that sauce.

The flavor of this sauce is a combination of creamy, vinegary, and herby. This makes it the perfect addition to practically any option on the menu.

However, it is particularly delicious with chicken options and salads. For the ultimate taste sensation, this works as a great dipping sauce for stuffed jalapenos.

7. Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce

Another amazing sauce from the huge range at Jack In The Box is the honey mustard dipping sauce. This is a classic combination that provides an initial sweetness from the honey and then a sharp twist from the mustard.

This is a sauce that people either love or hate. However, when it is paired with the right food, it can really enhance your meal.

The honey mustard dipping sauce is particularly good when paired with chicken orders. It also works as much more than just a dipping sauce.

Slathering this sauce on your sandwich or salad is the perfect way to elevate your meal.

8. Tartar Sauce

You might be a little confused as to why tartar sauce has ended up on the list of best sauces from Jack In The Box.

Although this sauce is most commonly served with fish, which isn’t the main attraction of Jack In The Box, it can also be used for other food as well.

Tartar sauce has one of the most unique flavors of any sauce at Jack In The Box. The vinegary tang of the sauce actually works surprisingly well with breaded chicken options such as sandwiches or salads.

The tang of tartar sauce also provides a great way to give your meal a little kick without overpowering more delicate flavors with too much spice.

Try this sauce with your sides such as onion rings and fries for a new taste experience.

9. Jack’s Mystery Sauce

This might be the most intriguing and fun sauce that you can order from Jack In The Box. Jack’s mystery sauce is the perfect way to keep some mystery and surprise in your meal.

This is the perfect choice for anyone who wants to change things up from their regular order.

It is difficult to accurately describe what Jack’s mystery sauce is thanks to the mysterious nature of the product.

However, people who have ordered this sauce have claimed that it could be a combination of ketchup, mayo, mustard, hot sauce, and onion relish.

Jack’s mystery sauce is essentially a mix of individual sauces that can be ordered from Jack In The Box. We would hazard a guess that it doesn’t include all 27 sauces available because it still tastes palatable.

The best thing about this sauce is that it goes with anything on the Jack In The Box menu.

10. Jack In The Box Ketchup

No list of best sauces would be complete without classic ketchup. To some people, this choice might be too obvious or even boring. However, the ketchup at Jack In The Box isn’t just any old ketchup.

Jack In The Box makes their own ketchup which has a unique tangy flavor that sets it apart from ketchup that other fast food restaurants offer.

Just like every other kind of ketchup, this is a super versatile sauce that is perfect for covering your burger or dipping your sides and fries.

Many visitors to Jack In The Box restaurants like to combine the ketchup sauce with two other sauces available in an attempt to recreate the famous Jack’s mystery sauce.

11. Creamy Bacon Mayo Sauce

If you want something that is a little smokier and adds a beautiful flavor to your meal, the creamy bacon mayo sauce is just what you need. This sauce is most commonly used in Jack In The Box sandwiches.

It is also much thicker than the other sauces that are available at Jack In The Box.

The thick texture of this sauce makes it perfect for topping burgers and sandwiches. It also works really well poured over fries in a way that is similar to making dirty fries.

The thicker texture and bits of bacon in the sauce mean that it isn’t the best option if your main goal is to dip sides.

This is a sauce that works really well when combined with other sauces that are available at Jack In The Box.

For example, using the creamy bacon mayo on your sandwich and then drizzling some of Frank’s hot sauce on top creates a taste sensation that makes your sandwich 100 times better.

Final Thoughts

Jack In The Box offers one of the most impressive ranges of sauces of any fast food restaurant in the country.

However, as with any range that is perhaps a little too large, there are some sauces that are better than others. The sauces in this list are particularly popular and will truly enhance your meal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Most Popular Sauce At Jack In The Box?

This is quite a subjective question and probably alters wildly between each store. However, if you have never been to Jack In The Box and want to have the ultimate first experience, there are two sauces that you can’t go wrong with.

Jack’s hot wings sauce and the garlic herb butter pair so well with pretty much anything that you can order from the menu.

However, if you are feeling a little more adventurous and want to have a first-time experience that honors the comedy beginnings of this restaurant, Jack’s mystery sauce is a must.

This is a really interesting sauce that adds some fun and excitement to your standard burger joint meal. It is also great as both a dipping sauce and a sauce for your burger.

Can You Buy Jack In The Box Sauce To Take Home?

Technically, the answer to this question is, yes. It is possible to order sauces at a Jack In The Box restaurant and take it home. However, there is a small caveat.

Whether you are ordering at the drive-thru, in the store to take out, or via a delivery service such as Uber Eats, you can order additional sauces that you aren’t going to use on your order.

This allows you to have a supply of Jack In The Box sauces at home whenever you want.

The caveat that comes with this is that you can only order the sauces in the small pouches or containers that are offered with your meal.

This is fine if you only want a couple of packets of sauce at home for when you are craving them or want to add them to a meal you cooked at home.

However, if you want enough to have the sauce on hand for whenever you want to use it, it can be inconvenient. Unfortunately, there is no way to purchase these sauces in bulk or in bigger packaging.

With that being said, there is no reason why Jack In The Box won’t begin to offer larger bottles of their sauces in the future if the demand is high enough for it to be profitable.

For now, though, you will have to make do with collecting as many individual packets of sauce as possible on each trip to the restaurant.

Can You Make Jack In The Box Sauces At Home?

This is a great question considering that you can’t purchase the sauces in large quantities easily.

There are a few copycat recipes available online for a handful of the 27 sauces available at Jack In The Box. However, the flavor of these sauces can be a little hit and miss.

Jack In The Box has never released a recipe for any of their sauces, particularly Jack’s mystery sauce.

However, each of the individual packets of sauce comes with a list of ingredients on the back so that you can identify allergens.

This list of ingredients can be used as a starting point to try and recreate the sauces at home.

Because there aren’t any quantities mentioned on the ingredients list it will be a case of trial and error to try and get close to the true Jack In The Box flavor.

Although you are unlikely to be able to replicate the flavors and textures of the sauce at home, that doesn’t mean that you can’t give it a go and see how close you can get.

About Maria Foster
Maria Foster
Maria Foster is a mother of 3 and she and her husband of 23 years share their home with 2 faithful dogs. Besides being CEO of the household and active in her community, Maria is the lead contributor to Food Champs and loves to try new food ideas and kitchen accessories to make easier and more delicious meals.
Maria Foster
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *