Home » Drinks » 12 Delicious Sonic Milkshakes You Need To Check Out

12 Delicious Sonic Milkshakes You Need To Check Out

Maria Foster
Last Updated on
by Maria Foster

If you are desperate for classic American diner-style food, then you know that Sonic Drive-In is always a safe bet.

Sonic specializes in classic American-style food, and that is what makes it so great. With such a huge range of classic American diner-style food to choose from, you’ll be spoiled for choice at Sonic.

12 Delicious Sonic Milkshakes You Need to Check Out

There are lots of different things that might attract you to Sonic Drive-In. You might visit because you are in the mood for a juicy cheeseburger or craving some salty fries.

But no matter what attracts you to Sonic, there is one thing that you likely will not leave without. That is, of course, a milkshake.

Sonic Drive-In offers some of the best milkshakes in the country, and with such a wide range of flavors to choose from it is easy to see what the big attraction is to this store.

In this guide, we’re taking a look at 12 of the most delicious Sonic milkshakes you need to check out. We’ve included both classic and master shakes in this guide, so no matter what you’re interested in, we’ve got you covered.

So, if you want to find out more about some delicious milkshakes you need to check out at Sonic Drive-In, keep on reading!

What Are Sonic Classic Shakes?

Before you order a Sonic milkshake, you need to know that there are two different kinds of milkshake that you might order at Sonic: a classic milkshake, and a master shake.

As the name suggests, a classic milkshake is a little more classic with traditional flavors and a basic design. While master shakes are complex with multiple flavors and ingredients.

If you are interested in a simple milkshake, then you will want to opt for a classic flavor. Classic shakes have a single flavor to them and come served with whipped cream and a cherry on top – just like a traditional milkshake.

While classic milkshakes are inspired by traditional milkshakes that were first incredibly popular during the 1950s, they do not just come in classic flavors.

As we will see shortly, Sonic offers classic flavors such as vanilla and strawberry, but they also offer more exciting, modern flavors in their classic shakes too.

If you are hoping for a milkshake that is a little more exciting, then you might opt for one of Sonic’s master shakes. With that in mind, let’s take a look at what a Sonic Master shake is.

12 Delicious Sonic Milkshakes You Need to Check Out

What Are Sonic Master Shakes?

As we have established, a Sonic classic shake is a classic style of milkshake. So, what is the difference between this and a Sonic Master shake? Well, there are a couple of differences between these two types of shakes.

Sonic Master shakes are essentially an enhanced version of their classic shakes. The ingredients used inside the shake tend to include more than one flavor and will generally be fancier than the flavor of a classic shake.

Master shakes also tend to come with additional toppings. In addition to the whipped cream and cherry that come as standard on a classic milkshake, you will also often find Graham Cracker crumbs or other toppings on a Master shake.

The additional toppings will depend on the flavor of the shake that you order.

Quite often, the menu for Sonic master shakes will vary throughout the year as seasonal additions are added to the menu. But most of the time, you will find a variety of different cheesecake options on the menu.

The key difference between a classic shake and a master shake is that classic shakes tend to be smooth to consume.

The classic flavors complement the milk and ice cream in the shake perfectly creating a drink that is utterly delicious.

In contrast, master shakes tend to vary greatly in terms of consistency. That is without even considering the difference in flavor.

Essentially, if you want a smooth, classic milkshake with a traditional flavor, then you will order a classic milkshake.

In contrast, if you want something innovative and exciting, then a master shake will be the right choice for you!

Now without further ado, let’s dive into the best flavors to choose from.

12 Delicious Sonic Milkshakes You Need To Check Out

There are lots of utterly delicious flavors of milkshakes on offer at Sonic Drive-In, and that is why so many people visit here for their milkshake needs.

With such a wide variety of different products on offer, you’ll never grow bored with the variety at Sonic, and will always find a milkshake flavor that tickles your taste buds.

If you are struggling to decide which option you fancy on any specific day, you’re in the right place.

Below we’ve done a round-up of the 12 most delicious Sonic milkshakes that you need to check out if you are a lover of these drinks.

So without further ado, let’s dive in!

1. Vanilla Classic Shake

Let’s kick off this list with an ultimate classic, and that is the vanilla milkshake. Some people will call a vanilla milkshake boring (or vanilla), but in our experience, it is one of the best shakes available at Sonic.

You really cannot go wrong with a Vanilla classic shake. There is something sweet and special about the flavor of the vanilla, and it creates a drink that is a home comfort in a cup.

Vanilla classic shakes are simple, and some people dislike this, but if you don’t know what to order, it is always a good idea to opt for this shake!

As you would expect, the vanilla classic shake at Sonic is created using vanilla ice cream.

The ice cream is blended to create a drink that is thick and creamy. It has rich flavors of vanilla and sweet undertones of custard.

When topped with whipped cream and a cherry, this milkshake looks as classic as you can get. So you really need to check it out!

2. Strawberry Classic Shake

If you are hoping for a classic flavor, but aren’t interested in a vanilla shake, then you might instead opt for a strawberry classic shake.

Strawberry is another classic flavor, and it is a little more exciting than the vanilla option that we looked at earlier.

For anyone who enjoys fruity flavors, a strawberry classic shake is absolutely perfect. It combines the thick and creamy texture of the milkshake with the light and fruity flavor of the strawberries perfectly.

The best thing about the Sonic strawberry milkshake is that the flavor is reminiscent of the strawberry Quik shake flavor, so it really is a blast from the past.

Sonic’s strawberry classic shake is made using real strawberries, so it can be quite a thick shake.

Frozen strawberries are blended with strawberry ice cream to create a flavor that perfectly straddles the real and artificial tastes of these ingredients.

Topped with whipped cream and a cherry, this drink is one that you really need to taste to appreciate!

3. Chocolate Classic Shake

On the topic of traditional milkshake flavors, another one that you really need to consider is this chocolate classic shake from Sonic.

Sonic makes lots of incredible classic shakes, and their chocolate milkshake really is one of the best options on the menu.

In order to enjoy this milkshake, you have to be somebody who loves chocolate. The chocolate classic shake at Sonic is rich and couldn’t ever be any flavor other than chocolate. It is unapologetically chocolate-flavored but in a very simple way.

This milkshake is chocolate-flavored in its most basic form, so that is something to bear in mind when you order.

The chocolate classic shake at Sonic is one of the thinnest milkshakes that the company has on offer. However, that doesn’t make it any less delicious.

If you want a classic chocolate shake that will have you reminiscing on the shakes you drank in childhood, this is the drink to buy!

4. Caramel Classic Shake

One of the flavors on the “classic” menu at Sonic Drive-In that isn’t actually that traditional is the caramel classic shake.

This shake belongs on the classic menu because of the way in which it is prepared, rather than because of its classic flavor but that doesn’t make it any less delicious.

We love the classic caramel shake because it is incredibly flavorful. This is a super bold flavor of milkshake and that is what makes it so amazing.

Every single slurp of this milkshake will tickle your taste buds and leave you longing for more. It really is absolutely incredible.

The Sonic caramel shake is special because it is made combining vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce.

The blending of the sauce makes the shake a lot thicker than some of the other shakes on this list, and that is something we personally love.

This milkshake is very rich and not for those who like a delicate shake. But it is definitely worth giving a whirl!

5. Banana Classic Shake

Another outstanding classic flavor of shake to check out is the banana classic shake.

This classic flavor of milkshake is perfect for anyone who wants the home comfort of a banana milkshake. It is thick and flavorful and made fresh, so it tastes even better than you would expect.

The banana classic shake is perfect for anyone who wants a milkshake that is packed with fresh fruit. The artificial banana flavoring is totally overpowered by the use of fresh bananas in this drink.

There is a lot of banana used in the making of this shake, so it’s safe to say if you dislike bananas, you should give this shake a miss.

The banana classic shake at Sonic is another super thick shake. The combination of ice cream, banana flavoring, and actual banana combines to create a drink that is super thick.

So make sure you pick up a large straw to enjoy this drink through. Once you’ve tasted the banana shake once, it will quickly become your go-to order.

6. Hot Fudge Classic Shake

We looked at the chocolate classic shake a little earlier, and there’s no denying that that shake is a little simplistic.

So, if you are looking for a chocolate milkshake that is more flavorful and unique in its chocolate flavor, you should check out the hot fudge classic shake.

The hot fudge classic shake is a delicious milkshake that perfectly combines the flavor of hot fudge with chocolate (just like in a hot chocolate fudge cake).

If you like your chocolate milkshakes to have a dark chocolate flavor, then this shake is perfect for you. The deep flavor of the fudge perfectly mimics dark chocolate, making it totally delicious.

Just like all classic shakes, this yummy drink is topped with whipped cream and a cherry before being served.

The whipped cream perfectly contrasts the rich flavor of the hot fudge creating a yummy drink that everyone will love. If your kids haven’t tried this drink yet, we would recommend letting them give it a try!

7. Reese’s Peanut Butter Classic Shake

The final classic shake that we had to include in this list is the Reese’s Peanut Butter Classic shake. This shake is perfect for any fans of peanut butter and totally different from any of the other shakes we have included so far in this guide.

If you love Reese’s Peanut Butter cups, then this shake is pretty much made for you. As the name suggests, this shake is designed to taste exactly like Reese’s Peanut Butter treats and that is achieved by using these treats within the shake.

For this very reason, this shake tends to be incredibly rich in flavor and very thick in texture.

If you thought that the banana shake was thick, you’re in for a treat with this shake. The broken-up Reese’s pieces really thicken up this shake and can be known to get stuck in your straw.

So prepare yourself that drinking this shake can be a little bit of a chore, but the flavor is totally worth it so you definitely need to give it a try!

8. Oreo Espresso Shake

Moving on from classic shakes, we have one of two Oreo-flavored shakes that you need to check out. The Oreo Espresso shake is a totally unique shake, and something really special.

If you love the flavor of Oreos and also love the taste of coffee, this is the milkshake for you.

This decadent shake is made using Oreo cookies, ice cream, and coffee syrup to create a flavor that really mimics that of a chocolate mocha.

It is essentially a cold version of this drink created using coffee syrup rather than coffee itself. So it is great for anyone avoiding caffeine too.

The Oreo Espresso shake really is one of the most delicious drinks on the menu at Sonic. However, it isn’t actually a permanent item on the menu. This is actually a limited edition drink so it enters the menu periodically throughout the year.

For that very reason, if you see this item available on the menu we’d urge you to jump on it while you have the chance!

9. Oreo Cheesecake Master Shake

Another great shake to check out if you love Oreos is the Oreo Cheesecake Master shake. This is the first master shake on this list, and a great one to check out if you enjoy Oreos and chocolate flavors.

The Oreo cheesecake master shake is created using Oreo cookies, Graham crackers, ice cream, and caramel sauce are combined to create this delicious shake.

You might not expect these flavors to effectively create a drink that tastes exactly like Oreo cheesecake, but this drink does exactly that.

This Oreo cheesecake master shake is easily one of the best master shakes on the menu. So if you haven’t tried it yet, be certain to give it a go!

10. Cheesecake Master Shake

If you like the idea of a cheesecake-flavored shake but aren’t a fan of Oreos, then you should check out the cheesecake master shake.

This shake is created using a similar technique to the Oreo cheesecake master shake, however, Oreos are omitted from the recipe.

Most of the time, vanilla will be used instead of Oreos to create a delicious vanilla cheesecake-flavored milkshake.

It is essentially a base-level cheesecake milkshake, but it is perfect for anyone who likes a basic cheesecake rather than something fancy.

This vanilla cheesecake master shake is perfect for any fans of New York cheesecake. It is thick and creamy and tastes exactly like a blended New York cheesecake. If you haven’t tasted it yet, you really need to!

11. Strawberry Cheesecake Master Shake

Alternatively, if your cheesecake of choice is a strawberry cheesecake, then this master shake is pretty much made for you.

This shake is created using the same base ingredients as the other cheesecake-flavored master shakes we have looked at, but strawberries are used to give it its unique and special flavor.

Just like the other milkshakes that we looked at earlier which used fruit, this strawberry cheesecake master shake is a very thick shake.

The strawberries in the shake tend to be very chunky and have been known to get caught in the straw from time to time. So bear this in mind when you take a large slurp of this shake.

As this milkshake is a “master” shake, it isn’t just strawberries that are used to create the delicious flavor of this drink.

Graham crackers are used to give the crunch associated with cheesecake, and caramel sauce is used to give it that subtle flavor.

The ice cream gives this milkshake a thick texture and the strawberries are the perfect finishing touch. All in all, this is just a great shake to try!

12. Oreo and Reese’s Peanut Butter Master Shake

Finally, we couldn’t create this guide without including one of Sonic’s most popular master shakes – the Oreo and Reese’s Peanut Butter master shake. If you love Reese’s and you love Oreos, you will absolutely adore this milkshake.

This master shake combines two of the most popular flavors of shakes at Sonic to create something truly special.

The sweet flavor of the Oreos is perfectly complemented by the tang of Reese’s peanut butter, and the chocolatey taste of the Oreos gives this master shake a nice sweet undertone.

To create this shake, the Oreos and Reese’s peanut butter pieces are combined with ice cream and a number of sauces.

A delicate balance of different ingredients is essential to master the flavor of this delicious shake. Too much peanut butter or too little Oreos and the entire milkshake will be thrown into disarray.

This master shake really is a work of art. So, if you like Reese’s peanut butter pieces and Oreos, you need to give this shake a whirl!


In short, there are lots of delicious styles of milkshakes to choose from at Sonic. Sonic offers both classic and master shakes so you have a wide variety of different styles and flavor options.

In this guide, we’ve taken a look at everything you need to know about the milkshakes offered at Sonic Drive-In, including a round-up of the 12 flavors you really need to try. So if you love a milkshake, we’ve got you covered.

We hope this information has helped you – thank you for reading!

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Sonic Make Great Milkshakes?

Yes, Sonic does make great milkshakes! The milkshakes served at Sonic really are some of the best fast-food milkshakes out there.

They are created using top-quality ingredients and are extra special as they are totally handmade. When you order a Sonic milkshake it is made specially for you, and that is what makes it so great!

Are Sonic Milkshakes Made With Ice Cream?

Sonic milkshakes are made using ice cream in-store, and that is part of the reason why they are so amazing.

Sonic milkshakes are made fresh using a variety of different ice creams to achieve specific flavors. This is what makes them so thick and creamy, and why they are so popular across the USA!

About Maria Foster
Maria Foster
Maria Foster is a mother of 3 and she and her husband of 23 years share their home with 2 faithful dogs. Besides being CEO of the household and active in her community, Maria is the lead contributor to Food Champs and loves to try new food ideas and kitchen accessories to make easier and more delicious meals.
Maria Foster
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *